Everything here is made from scratch, and they do fritter-style and cake doughnuts, including some exotic ones with hibiscus syrup and candied bacon.
— Food & Drink
Each donut is a gustatory work of art, a blank canvas for the Pidgeon’s creativity.
— Victoria Shearer, FL Keys & KW Chef's Table
A taste of the tropics at the southernmost doughnut shop in the continental USA, where the line often stretches out the door. They have some really great island flavors…key limes and lemons and pina coladas.
— USA Today
…Glazed Donuts’ signature glazed donut was delicious…Krispy Kreme’s glazed donuts should be ashamed of themselves.
— Jeff Richman, Jeff Eats
The glazed were…unparalleled. If ever in Key West, this is a definite must have!
— Elizabeth Halle, Little Moments of Happiness
Glazed Donuts offers organic coffees, sloshed with scalded milk in café con leche. Try it with the maple bourbon and candied Canadian bacon doughnut — it’s a pairing any true Miamian would approve of.
— Miami New Times